Myth Busting: Water and Temperature with Cold Process Soap
Ask a dozen soapmakers about the best temperature or water amount for cold process soap, and you’ll probably get a dozen different answers. Some swear by soaping hot, others prefer room temperature, and everyone seems to have their own rules about how much water to use.
But how much of what we’ve been taught is actually true? And how much depends on the oils we’re using, the formulation, and the way we make our soap?
In this Myth Busting course, we’re putting some of those common soapmaking beliefs to the test with hands-on experiments, different formulations, and plenty of observations along the way.
Exploring Water, Temperature, and Fatty Acid Profiles
We’ll explore how water amounts and soaping temperatures influence cold process soap, including how different fatty acid profiles respond to changes in these variables.
Using formulations such as 100% coconut oil and 100% olive oil soap, we’ll investigate:
- How water-to-sodium-hydroxide ratios affect soap batter
- How different temperatures influence trace and setup
- Why fatty acid profiles matter when choosing your soaping temperatures
- How water content affects unmolding and cure
- What happens when we isolate individual variables and repeat experiments under more controlled conditions
You’ll get to see the experiments, review the observations, and explore what worked, what surprised us, and what we might do differently.
An Unexpected Discovery: Dreaded Orange Spots!
More than a year after making our original test soaps, we revisited them while exploring naturally white soaps during our Year of the Rainbow project. What we found was fascinating! Although all of the soaps started out uncolored, they hadn’t aged the same way. Some were still beautifully pale, while others had yellowed or developed signs of dreaded orange spots (DOS).
These observations raised some interesting questions about whether water content, soaping temperature, and heat retention during saponification might influence how soap ages. We already know that oxidation is complicated, but could some of the choices we make during soapmaking contribute to the development of DOS months or even years later?
That’s what we’re exploring in our newest experiment, which builds on the original Myth Busting course and gives us an opportunity to follow these soaps over a full year.
Follow Our Year-Long DOS Investigation
In August 2026, we launched a new controlled experiment to explore the relationship between water content, temperature, heat retention, and long-term DOS development.
We’re following these soaps over an entire year, documenting their changes as they age.
Our ongoing observations include:
- Changes in color and the appearance of dreaded orange spots
- Odor, texture, and hardness changes
- Weight loss and curing behavior
- Differences between low-water and higher-water formulations
- How temperature and heat retention may influence long-term soap behavior
We’ll also explore the cure-weight data collected during the experiment and what those measurements reveal about water loss and practical cure time.
This is a real, ongoing investigation. We’re not promising a magical answer to what causes DOS. We’re observing, testing, asking questions, and sharing what we discover along the way.
What’s Included
- Hands-on cold process soapmaking experiments
- Video lessons and class replays
- Experimental formulations, charts, and observations
- Follow-up tests and findings
- The ongoing year-long DOS investigation
- Cure-weight observations and analysis
- New documentation and updates as the experiments progress
Let’s Bust Some Soapmaking Myths!
Whether you’re trying to better understand trace, refine your soapmaking process, troubleshoot unexpected results, or figure out why your beautiful soap developed orange spots months later, this course offers a closer look at what really happens inside our soap batches.
Your purchase includes lifetime access to the course and its ongoing updates.
Happy soaping!


Reviews
There are no reviews yet